Question :
A question was asked about the ruling of clapping when it is appropriate or in social gatherings.
Fatwa in Brief: Clapping is a manifestation of
pre-Islamic ignorance; at the very least, it is disliked
(makruh).
Shaykh Ibn Baz, Fatawa Mu‘asira, p. 67
Response:
Clapping at appropriate times is not worship and is not
a means of drawing closer to God. It is a cultural
tradition; and a way in which some people choose to
express themselves when amazed or surprised by [or
appreciative of] something. There is nothing that
prohibits this [clapping] in Muslim law.
Commentary:
Those who draw close to God by whistling and clapping
are wrong. This is pointed out by al-Qurtubi in his
interpretation [of the Qur’an] (tafsir),
when he criticizes the ignorance of the Sufis who dance
and clap. [In his view] Such behaviour is contrary to
the spirit of Islam, and in opposition to rational
thought. It is the kind of behaviour that people used to
do in their houses [before Islam enlightened them].
However, the type of clapping mentioned in this fatwa
is not worship. Further, it does not suggest that anyone
is attempting to draw closer to God. It is a cultural
tradition; and a way in which some people choose to
express themselves when amazed or surprised by [or
appreciative of] something. There is nothing that
prohibits this [clapping] in Muslim law. It is better,
however, not to do it during celebrations that take
place in the mosque. For, in this way, Muslims
distinguish themselves from the unbelievers (kuffar).
Scholars mention that it is permitted to clap at times
other than during prayer and the sermon (khutbah).
There should first be a need for this, such as when
someone wishes to seek permission [for a request], or
wishes to alert someone, or to embellish a [Islamically
permitted] song (nashid), or when women and
children play. When there is no need for clapping,
however, this practice is disliked (makruh).[1]
And God knows best.
Dr. Anas Abu Shadi
[1]
Radd al-Muhtaar 395/6, Tuhfatul
al-Muhtaaj 150/2, Al-Fatawa al-Fiqheyah
al-Kubra 356/4.
|